Open side-bar Menu
 ArchShowcase
Sanjay Gangal
Sanjay Gangal
Sanjay Gangal is the President of IBSystems, the parent company of AECCafe.com, MCADCafe, EDACafe.Com, GISCafe.Com, and ShareCG.Com.

The David and Lucile Packard Foundation Headquarters in California by EHDD

 
April 24th, 2014 by Sanjay Gangal

Article source: EHDD

Project Overview

The headquarters for The David and Lucile Packard Foundation in Los Altos, California brings staff, grantees and partners together to solve the world’s most intractable problems. Passive, bioclimatic design strategies support the core philanthropic mission while serving as the basis of the net zero energy (NZE) and LEED Platinum building performance.

View of entry lobby and Second Street landscape with rain gardens in the foreground, Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

View of entry lobby and Second Street landscape with rain gardens in the foreground, Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

  • Architects: EHDD
  • Project: The David and Lucile Packard Foundation Headquarters
  • Location: California, U.S.A
  • Photography: Jeremy Bittermann, EHDD
  • Project Completion Date: July, 2012
  • Principal in Charge: Scott Shell
  • Design Principal: Marc L’Italien
  • Project Manager: Brad Jacobson
  • Project Architect – Exterior: Terry McCormick
  • Project Architect – Interior: Lotte Kaefer
  • Owner’s Representative: Linda Rhodes
  • Commissioning Agent: Amir Yazdi
  • Structural Engineer: David Mar
  • Mechanical and Plumbing: Peter Rumsey
  • Electrical: David Kaneda
  • Civil Engineering: Bry Sarte
  • Landscape: Joni Janecki
  • Lighting: Janet Nolan
  • Acoustical: Charles Salter
  • Code Consultant: Jeff Maddox
  • Controls System (SCADA): Raymond Clarke
  • Fire Protection: Jennifer Doty
  • General Contractor: Mike Humphrey

The Packard Foundation’s connection to the Los Altos community dates back to its inception in 1964. For two decades, as the Foundation’s grantmaking programs expanded locally and internationally, staff and operations have been scattered in various buildings. This project enhances proximity and collaboration while renewing the Foundation’s commitment to its local community. The project’s focus on sustainability brings the Foundation’s facilities into alignment with its core work of conserving and restoring the Earth’s natural systems. Its new home–the largest building to date to receive Net Zero Energy Building Certification™ through the International Living Future Institute–is the cornerstone of its effort to demonstrate how an organization can improve its effectiveness and the quality of life for its employees while emitting carbon at the rate needed to keep temperature rise below 2°C.

Design & Innovation

Narrative: 

The project vision was not to design a sustainable building, but to advance the Foundation’s sustainability as an organization. An integrated design team, including transportation planners, sustainable food experts and a newly formed Sustainable Task Force, began with an assessment of the Foundation’s overall impacts. Staff commuting, travel and building energy use each represented roughly one-third of their emissions. The team then developed a range of strategies to address each of these sectors.

Organizational Carbon Footprint (2007) with short (2013) and long term (2050) reduction targets. The project looked beyond building energy use towards a wide range of carbon emissions sources.,  Image Courtesy © EHDD

Organizational Carbon Footprint (2007) with short (2013) and long term (2050) reduction targets. The project looked beyond building energy use towards a wide range of carbon emissions sources.,
Image Courtesy © EHDD

With the overall greenhouse-gas footprint as the ultimate measure for project success, the project team aimed for eliminating net annual gas and electricity use while aggressively addressing transportation impacts through the project process. Design choices were passed through a “replicability” filter: the goal was not the least cost, but to identify best practices that within a decade were poised to transform the building marketplace at a competitive cost.

Sustainable systems diagram., Image Courtesy © EHDD

Sustainable systems diagram., Image Courtesy © EHDD

Perhaps most importantly, the project set out to prove that a more sustainable life is simply a better life. Occupants reported the biggest change they experienced during their first year in the building was how the courtyard and adjacent common spaces increased the sense of community and improved the quality of everyday life.

Regional/Community Design

Narrative: 

The Foundation’s greenhouse-gas footprint analysis identified transportation emissions as the biggest sector with individual car commuting as the single biggest emissions source. While local zoning code required 160 parking spaces, the team documented a much lower demand for 67 spaces and developed a Transportation Demand Management Plan (TDMP) to reduce demand further over time. Coordination with the City of Los Altos allowed the elimination of a planned $8 million underground garage from the project, thereby reducing project embodied carbon emissions by one-quarter, all while incentivizing alternative modes of commuting. A “last mile” shuttle from their building to the rail station also picks up others along its path, improving connectivity and transit options for the greater community.

Site and Context Plan,  Image Courtesy © EHDD

Site and Context Plan,
Image Courtesy © EHDD

The team exploited feedbacks between the building project and air travel-related emissions as well. Remote collaboration technologies such as video conferencing are integrated into all meeting spaces. Over time the staff hopes to reduce travel and improve quality of life by connecting virtually with grantees and others whenever possible.

View looking south., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

View looking south., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Land Use & Site Ecology

Narrative: 

Until World War II Los Altos was an agricultural town dominated by apricot orchards. By the 21st century, the project site was 97 percent impervious, covered in substandard, mostly unoccupied buildings and asphalt parking lots two blocks from Main Street. The challenge was how to densify and enliven the historic downtown with daytime office workers while improving site ecology in the process.

A building set within a vibrant, regenerative ecosystem., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

A building set within a vibrant, regenerative ecosystem., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

The end result is a porous and transparent building set in a climate-appropriate landscape that reduced site imperviousness to 35 percent. Ninety percent of the plants are native to California and were sourced within 500 miles. The landscape is split down the center of the site into “grassland” and “woodland” ecosystems, reinforcing the building parti while demonstrating the layered landscape of native plant communities. A 25-year old live oak tree in the entry court was grown from an acorn on a Packard family-owned property. The western columbine, which was Lucile Packard’s favorite flower, adorns the sidewalk rain gardens. A green roof visible from the second floor hallways and boardroom is enlivened by a variety of shallow rooting, low growing succulents planted to create a mosaic similar to the bluffs on the California coast.

View of green roof from second floor balcony., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

View of green roof from second floor balcony., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Bioclimatic Design

Narrative: 

Sometimes good urbanism and energy efficiency can work against each other. Early on, the design team chose to align the building to the street grid–which is oriented 40 degrees off true north–in order to be good neighbors and affirm that sustainable buildings can “fit in.” The task was then set: if ALL direct sunlight could be kept out of southwest-facing spaces and extra attention was paid to glare control, the energy penalty would be kept to less than 5 percent as compared to an optimally oriented building.

Dynamic exterior blinds keep unwanted sun out of southwest-facing interiors, Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Dynamic exterior blinds keep unwanted sun out of southwest-facing interiors, Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

This was achieved by utilizing layering of sunshading and glare control strategies; including roof overhangs, balconies, trees, interior blinds and automated exterior blinds on all southwest-facing windows. The design is tuned for the uniquely benign California climate; emphasizing connectivity between indoor and outdoor spaces through an operable façade that opens up to invite staff to access the outdoors. The largest “room” in the project–the outdoor courtyard–functions as a casual meeting space set in a bucolic California landscape. Detailed design studies tested options to ensure a good outdoor micro-climate, with an optimized length, width and height for both winter warmth and summer cooling.

Building sections showing bioclimatic design strategies., Image Courtesy © EHDD

Building sections showing bioclimatic design strategies., Image Courtesy © EHDD

View of the courtyard., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

View of the courtyard., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Light & Air

Narrative: 

This is a building shaped by daylight and access to the outdoors. Two 40-foot wide office wings are pulled apart to create a landscaped courtyard space at the figurative and literal heart of the site. In that narrow building footprint, all occupants are within easy reach of daylight, views and operable windows. Natural ventilation displays on laptops and break rooms alert occupants when outdoor conditions are optimal for opening windows. Interior shades are user-controlled to combat glare, but automatically rise each night as a default. To harvest the potential energy savings made possible by the exceptional daylighting, electric lighting automatically dims when daylight levels suffice. Under-counter LED task lights are controlled by occupancy sensors at each desk. The daylighting design aimed for “perceptual brightness”-–a space so well daylit that no one thinks to override the lighting controls. To that end the design includes linear skylights and lightshelves throughout the upper floor and a ground floor made as tall as possible to extend the reach of daylight. The energy model predicted a 40% reduction in lighting energy but the first year measured results showed performance 26% better than modeled as the performance of the daylighting system exceeded expectations.

Design for daylighting, views and connection to the outdoors ,Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Design for daylighting, views and connection to the outdoors ,Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Water Cycle

Narrative: 

The Packard family founded the Monterey Bay Aquarium and its Research Institute to study and safeguard the health of our oceans and fisheries. This project continues with that tradition as it demonstrates best practices by absorbing stormwater flows and improving stormwater quality. Rainwater from the roof is routed to a 20,000-gallon underground cistern to meet 90 percent of toilet flushing and 60 percent of irrigation demand. It is the first rainwater for indoor use system in Los Altos. The cistern overflows into a detention pond designed to minimize any stormwater actually reaching the public storm system. Greywater systems were considered but ruled out due to the low source availability in an office building.

Ground and Second Floor Plans ,Image Courtesy © EHDD

Ground and Second Floor Plans ,Image Courtesy © EHDD

All runoff from impervious surfaces is treated via vegetated swales, rain gardens or underground infiltration basins. The project voluntarily retrofitted both sides of existing street frontage on Second Street by removing the sidewalk and constructing flow-through “rain gardens”–the first in Silicon Valley–which will treat and infiltrate road runoff. In sum, the stormwater peak flow rates and volumes are reduced approximately 50 percent from pre-project levels.

Energy Flows & Energy Future

Narrative: 

The net zero energy (NZE) approach is driven by daylighting, enhanced envelope design, highly efficient HVAC systems and an innovative effort to cut plug load energy in half. A 285 kW PV system is sized to meet yearly energy demand.

Triple-element glazing (R-7.7), detailing to eliminate thermal bridging and continuously insulated wood-framed walls (R-24) eliminate the need for perimeter heating. The low heating demand allows an all-electric (truly zero energy/carbon) system providing heating through ventilation supply air. Chilled beams and radiant panels provide cooling using chilled water created at night by compressor-free cooling towers and stored in 50,000-gallon underground tanks. Cooling energy is reduced 90 percent from a conventional chiller and VAV-reheat system.

A detailed Plug Load Study forecasted a 58% energy reduction, primarily through a defined purchasing protocol., Image Courtesy © EHDD

A detailed Plug Load Study forecasted a 58% energy reduction, primarily through a defined purchasing protocol., Image Courtesy © EHDD

A plug load management plan promised a predicted 58% energy savings, primarily through a purchasing plan aimed at buying the top 5% of Energy Star equipment. First year plug load energy savings exceeded predictions.

Passive survivability is aided by rainwater storage, a thermal comfort approach based on an enhanced envelope and smaller systems, as well as daylighting, natural ventilation and solar electric/thermal energy generation. In the first year of operation, the building was energy positive with a net energy use intensity (EUI) of -4 kBtu/sf/yr.

Materials & Construction

Narrative: 

Material resource conservation strategies took many forms:

Embodied carbon – Emissions were reduced through use of a wood/steel hybrid structure and wood-framed walls while the concrete mix featured 70 percent cement replacement using slag. The total embodied CO2 of 1,790 tons pays off in 4.4 years when compared with current yearly operational CO2 of 409 tons, justifying the construction of a new NZE building.

Deconstruction – 95 percent of materials from deconstruction were diverted from landfill.

Wood, stone, copper and glass honestly express modern construction while highlighting the beauty of naturally-finished materials., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Wood, stone, copper and glass honestly express modern construction while highlighting the beauty of naturally-finished materials., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Material sourcing – All wood was FSC-certified or salvaged including wood veneer sourced from Eucalyptus trees felled during the Doyle Drive rebuilding project in San Francisco, California. Exterior wood is FSC-certified western red cedar. Stone is Mt. Moriah from the border of Utah and Nevada, within a 500-mile radius from the site. The exterior copper is 75-percent recycled, with a long life span and integral finish. Vertical application and low pH levels in west coast rain eliminates risk from leaching of “ionic copper” into waterways which can be found in roof applications in acidic environments.

Use reduction – Advanced wall framing techniques with studs at 24 inches on center saved wood and reduced thermal bridging by increasing the area available for wall insulation.

Long Life, Loose Fit

Narrative: 

This project is meant to house the Packard Foundation in their ancestral town for the remainder of the 21st century, so the quality of materials and detailing reflect this intent. For example, beams and trusses tend to span without intermediate columns to allow for future reconfiguration; Truss ends exposed to the weather are bolted on to allow replacement in the event of weathering; integral finish materials that invite weathering like stone, copper and wood adorn the exterior.

A diversity of indoor and outdoor meeting spaces provides a range of collaborative environments., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

A diversity of indoor and outdoor meeting spaces provides a range of collaborative environments., Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

In the San Francisco Bay Area, however, building life expectancy is governed as much by earthquakes as other factors. Therefore the team opted to upgrade the seismic lateral system using rocking and restoring braced frames: a self-centering innovation in which the frames are designed to first yield and then return to plumb during a major earthquake. Structural fuses designed to absorb seismic forces can be easily and inexpensively replaced.

Twelve modular office “neighborhoods” provide flexibility for working groups as they change over time. Standardized building blocks of 120-square-foot “flex office/meeting rooms” and 80-square-foot workstations are composed to form the “neighborhoods.” The multi-functioning flex rooms can be reconfigured in the short and long term to serve multiple purposes.

Collective Wisdom & Feedback Loops

Narrative: 

Net zero energy (NZE) is not a design goal; it is an operational goal proven or disproven each year. The design team engaged with Foundation staff early to test energy model assumptions and ensure shared ownership of the goals and results. A “real world” energy model aimed to predict actual energy use by honing in on items such as plug loads and occupancy schedules. Post-occupancy phase services extended beyond user surveys to include monitoring and post-occupancy commissioning. Key team members remained involved for the first year to troubleshoot issues in real time and to document results and challenges.

Circuit-by-circuit monitoring provided a plethora of information about how energy is actually used and the extent to which energy model predictions align with reality. There are numerous active systems in the building all with monitoring and data. Many systems, like the thermal storage tanks for cooling, outperformed expectations, leading to less cooling and related pump and fan energy use. In contrast, heating energy use and related systems used more energy due to infiltration, thermal bridging, less lighting energy use and other factors. The overall results were in line with expectations; but the lessons learned will impact future NZE projects for those involved.

Other Information

Cost and Payback Analysis: 

A key project goal is to demonstrate the replicability of NZE projects, for which the ultimate question is “what is the additional cost?” Much about this project is unique, including the high baseline construction costs in the area. The cost of the “replicable warm shell”–including the roof, walls, windows, heating, cooling, plumbing, elevator, and photovoltaics–that allow the project to get to zero energy is $23.5 million or $477 per sq. ft. This compares favorably to other Class A office space in the area.

Perhaps a better way to understand the costs of NZE, however, is to look at specific building systems and how integrated design can reduce or eliminate additional costs. While the triple element windows (see Measure 7) cost more than standard windows, they boost the envelope performance enough to eliminate zonal heating and net a $75,000 first cost savings. Add the $300,000 saved in 35 kilowatts of avoided PV panels due to reduced heating demand, this solution shows that thoughtful system design does not need to cost more.

In another example, plug load energy savings reduced the required PV system by 85 kW or $400,000 in first cost.

Process and Results: 

Predesign: Programming for sustainability was a critical component of the project. The Foundation staff came from a traditional setting of large, private offices with meeting space in each office. Through programming, the project team came to a new model of smaller (120 square foot) private offices, more workstations and a variety of group work spaces. This process yielded significantly higher space utilization and lower energy use, while supporting emerging work styles.

Design: The energy model for this project has little resemblance to a compliance model. All assumptions, schedules and loads were examined by multiple team members in an attempt to estimate actual energy use as accurately as possible. The architect and energy modeler presented a unique “Energy Model Report” to the client, which helped explain “living” nature of the NZE goal and the Foundation’s responsibility for achieving it in operation.

Commissioning: There are numerous active systems requiring commissioning in the building in addition to M/E/P including: automated exterior sunshades, automated interior blinds, advanced lighting controls including daylight dimming and occupancy, plug load occupancy sensors and circuit-by-circuit monitoring, mechanical system controls, and IT and AV control systems. Since commissioning only occurs in an unoccupied building in one particular season, thorough commissioning required an extension of activities into the post-occupancy phase.

Measurement & verification/post-occupancy evaluation: The majority of activity centered on the mechanical system and its controls, as other active systems performed well. However, half of the air-source heat pumps failed, requiring diagnostics, repairs and upgrades. Through manual adjustments to the system, the building maintained operation while the units were repaired. With remote access to every point on each control system, the building can be monitored in real time. With just a phone call, the building operator was able to engage the post occupancy team, who could immediately access the current operation of the building and provide feedback, download information for further analysis, or schedule a site visit to investigate an issue.

Elevations, Image Courtesy © EHDD

Elevations, Image Courtesy © EHDD

View of the foyer with courtyard to the left, large meeting room to the right, and lobby beyond, Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

View of the foyer with courtyard to the left, large meeting room to the right, and lobby beyond, Image Courtesy © Jeremy Bittermann

Related posts:

Contact EHDD

Tags: ,

Category: Headquarters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

GRAPHISOFT: ARCHICAD download 30-day FREE trial
Graphisoft ARCHICAD  Download a 30-Day FREE trial
TurboCAD pro : Start at $299
CADalog.com - Countless CAD add-ons, plug-ins and more.



Internet Business Systems © 2016 Internet Business Systems, Inc.
595 Millich Dr., Suite 216, Campbell, CA 95008
+1 (408)-337-6870 — Contact Us, or visit our other sites:
TechJobsCafe - Technical Jobs and Resumes EDACafe - Electronic Design Automation GISCafe - Geographical Information Services  MCADCafe - Mechanical Design and Engineering ShareCG - Share Computer Graphic (CG) Animation, 3D Art and 3D Models
  Privacy Policy